Home Food Crush 5 Places to Get Cookies in Pensacola

5 Places to Get Cookies in Pensacola

Grinch cookies from Smallcakes.

Want to hear a holiday I can get behind? National Cookie Day! You can celebrate all day long with these five spots for cookies in Pensacola.


SMALLCAKES Best known for its mastery of the small cake…the cupcake, locally-owned Smallcakes has a variety of offerings, including COOKIES! You can get Christmas sugar cookies with glaze and Christmas buttercream cookies. They offer custom sugar cookie orders, with logos and/or simple buttercream designs. You can get classic chocolate chip cookies, snickerdoodles, M&M cookies, cookie sandwiches, Gluten Free chocolate chip and snickerdoodles, and Vegan oatmeal cream pies! During December they have gingerbread cookies and gingerbread decorating kits! Follow them on Facebook here: https://www.facebook.com/SmallcakesPensacola

J’S BAKERY Of course, a big favorite is J’s Bakery on 12th Avenue. J’s Bakery has served the people of Pensacola since 1946 with delicious cakes, petit fours, cookies, and confections of all shapes and sizes. J’s also carries donuts and their famous smiley face cookies that have become an after-school reward for many Pensacola school children. Straight A on a hard test? A smiley-face cookie stop is in order! Currently, J’s has Christmas and holiday cookies that will melt any Grinchy heart. Stop by J’s at 2014 N. 12th Avenue! More information here: https://jsbakeryandcafe.com/

GARMAN COOKIES Sheree’s name always pops up on the list of recommended custom cookie makers! Her cookies are a hit with taste and design. Although Garman is a custom cookie maker, she is active on social media and often has order opportunities for holidays. She can also be contacted for special events. These cookies are worthy of an Instagram post and tie a ribbon on an event theme. To see Garman’s cookies or to place an order, visit here: https://www.facebook.com/GarmanCookies/

CRUMBL Crumbl cookies aren’t a treat, they are a full-on girl dinner. Although Crumbl has a limited selection, the flavors rotate weekly. These thick, soft cookies a more than a mouthful and will send you on a sugar high. The pretty pink boxes are perfect for a birthday gift or office treat. Pro-tip: cut each cookie in quarters like a pie and sample with friends. This week you can indulge in Gingerbread, Chocolate Raspberry Truffle, or Twix Shortbread to name a few. Pair them with milk and you can skip your meal. There is a Crumbl located in north Pensacola and Gulf Breeze. Check out your location hours and weekly selections here: https://crumblcookies.com/

GREAT AMERICAN COOKIES The great thing about Great American Cookies is they keep late hours! If you get an early evening cookie craving, this is your place. Grab a cookie, a slice, or a whole cookie cake – then walk off your calories in the mall! If you go to their website, which is very user-friendly, they can make a custom cookie cake for your next event or occasion. https://www.greatamericancookies.com/

Pour a tall glass of milk and beat Cookie Monster there!

J’s Bakery has yummy Christmas tree cookies and old-fashioned thumbprint cookies!