Tis’ the season where the Prue from the Great British Baking Show comes out in me and I crave a warmed up, freshly baked anything. I am also attempting to have a 6-pack by Spring Break 2025. Watch me!
Pensacola is scattered with a savory selection of places to get a good pastry. “Good” may not cut it when we are talking about gourmet ganaches, homemade fillings, and muffins that melt in your mouth. This time of year is the perfect excuse to warm up with a cup of coffee and a freshly baked treat.
Baked goods come in handy during all sorts of occasions. They make for easy gifts, satiate the sweet tooth, and act as the perfect dish to bring for a holiday gathering. Our area is surrounded with local bakeries, coffee shops, and cafe’s serving up homemade treats daily.
There is something magical about bundling up in a big cozy jacket, ordering a coffee, and letting the baked goods speak to you.
Below, we’ve put together a local list of the best bakeries in town. Each business on the list below is as sweet as it sounds!
Adonna’s Garden St. Cafe and Bakery
Adonna’s is decking the cafe with Christmas spirit and a special menu this holiday season. Pair this with their classic selection of baked goods and sweet treats, and you’ll be sure to tell everyone you know. Call Adonna’s if you are looking for catering services or need an order for a large group!
Social Media: Instagram and Facebook
Alla Prima Coffee Roaster
Alla Prima Coffee Roaster is a full-service specialty coffee shop and micro roastery offering beverages, food, coffee, baked goods, roasting classes, and local fine art. They are highly caffeinated and creative in all that they do!
Social Media: Instagram and Facebook
Bodacious Cafe
This unique establishment prides itself on a commitment to local flavors and crafts, creating dishes that are not only inspired by the community but also crafted with ingredients sourced directly from local farmers and artisans.
Social Media: Instagram and Facebook
Cafe Single Fin
A radical cafe located on 9th Avenue serving predominantly vegan based baked goods and epic vibes. All bakery items are made in house and fresh every day!
Social Media: Instagram and Facebook
Chrisoula’s Cheesecake Shoppe
Chrisoula’s Cheesecake Shoppe started in 2007 with a passion for baking delicious cheesecakes that bring smiles and people together. Every cheesecake is made from scratch in small batches with love and care. They take pride in using only the freshest and finest ingredients.
Social Media: Instagram and Facebook
Craft Bakery
Jordan and her team at Craft Bakery bring a wide variety of flavors through their selection of craft pastries, breads, desserts, and coffees. You can taste the years of experience and culinary excellence in every bite!
Social Media: Instagram and Facebook
End of the Line
End of the Line offers a wide variety of healthy, organic, vegan food and treats made in house. The cafe serves a wide variety on their regular menu, as well as special weekly menus for Sunday Brunch.
Social Media: Instagram and Facebook
Fosko Coffee Barre
Known for their frisbee sized cookies and XL muffins, Fosko is a must try. Our shop diligently crafts in house recipes and products in our full bakery and kitchen, and we are also proud to work with a variety of local partners who help us indulge our customers in the most premium experience.
Social Media: Instagram
Good Day Darling Cafe
One of the most recent additions to the sweet treat community, welcome Good Day Darling Cafe! Their shop is made to welcome visitors and warm bellies with a variety of smoothies, treats, and eats! They are located in the heart of East Hill, drop in and welcome them to the neighborhood!
Social Media: Instagram
J’s Bakery and Cafe
From fresh doughnuts and pastries to an array of delightful cakes and cookies, our commitment to quality and tradition has made them a local institution. Owner Ryan Thomas and his dedicated team are proud to offer not only classic bakery delights but also a scrumptious breakfast and lunch menu, along with SMALL event catering services.
Social Media: Instagram and Facebook
Leisure Club Coffee & Brunch Bar
Serving breads, pastries, and treats since that’ll make you a regular at this spot! All made fresh in house and pairing perfectly with a warm latte.
Social Media: Instagram
Maker’s Cafe & Espresso Bar
A coffee shop/cafe that instantly feels worthy of your return. Their selection of fresh made pastries are made daily and typically gluten free. When we say melt in your mouth, the Olive Oil Cake will do just that.
Social Media: Instagram and Facebook
Maynard’s Donut Co.
All product baked fresh seven days a week and served with a smile from their amazing staff. They also serve kolaches, coffees, and churn their own ice cream!
Social Media: Facebook
Native Cafe
A beachy cafe popular for serving a homestyle breakfast and lunch. Their best kept secret is their spread of homemade desserts and pastries!
Social Media: Instagram and Facebook
There you have it folks! A fine list of where to fine the best tasting pastries in Pensacola. Help support small businesses while you satisfy your cravings for a fresh baked goodie!
With love from one of your favorite Local Pulse foodies, Makenna Curtis.
