Home Food Crush Pensacola’s Top 5 for the Best Key Lime Pie

Pensacola’s Top 5 for the Best Key Lime Pie

Photo by: My Florida Panhandle ft.Flounder's Chowder House, Key Lime Pie

We’re calling all Key Lime Pie lovers to the table! National Key Lime Pie Day is today and it is of strong opinion within the Local Pulse team that Key Lime Pie is one of the top-tasting types of pie.


This is good news people. The best advice we can give is to forward this article to your Key Lime Pie lovin’ friends if it is not your kind.

You’ve got the perfect mixture of tart and sweet. Met with the grounding effect of the graham cracker or nutty-based crust that makes it so desirable to eat. It’s the type of pie that clears the pallet, while also representing a tasty southern sweet treat.

We’ve got 5 places in Pensacola that’ve whipped up the best Key Lime Pie you can eat. Find this list below and let us know what you think!

Flounder’s Chowder House

Take your sweet tooth to the beach and try this recipe that’s been holding strong since 1979. “We settle the Age-Old argument by serving a homemade layered pie of both yellow and green with a generous squeeze of fresh lime when served.”

Address: 800 Quietwater Beach Rd, Gulf Breeze, FL 32561

Native Cafe

Native Cafe is breakfast and brunch didn’t you think? Don’t miss out on their gluten-free & homemade Key Lime Pie with walnut crust. Be the person who orders a slice of pie to share with the table or enjoy it as an after-brunch sweet treat.

Address: 45A Via De Luna Dr, Pensacola Beach, FL 32561

Chrisssoula’s Cheesecake Shoppe

Making our way downtown, you’ll find everything you need sweet at Chrissoula’s off of Garden Street. Don’t miss out on their handcrafted cheesecakes, specifically the Key Lime. You have the option to order one of their smaller bite sizes or the whole cheesecake! They are one of a kind.

Address: 236 W Garden St # 2a, Pensacola, FL 32502

The Oar House

Picture this: Sitting along the Bayou Chico, the sun is setting in the sky, and your waitress comes by with a tasty slice of Key Lime Pie. The tart flavor of key limes and blended cream makes a treat after all the seafood you eat!

Address: 1000 S Pace Blvd, Pensacola, FL 32502

Joe Patti’s

Always been a staple to Pensacola’s seafood history, but did you know they had pie? Some of the best we might add. Truly one of a kind. You won’t find this pie along the fish line. The market has a small store full of sauces, seasonings, and a special selection of sweet finds. Including but not limited to their famous Key Lime Pie

Address: 524 S B St, Pensacola, FL 32502

Join us in celebrating Key Lime Pie Day! If we are what we eat, we are not complaining that we get to be this sweet, tart, and Southern treat.